Transparency Disclosure: We may receive a fee from the seller for any purchases made through links on this website or from other sites accessed via this website. This fee incurs no additional costs for the buyer. To learn more, please read our full disclosure page here. Read our Product Research and Testing page to know more about our review process in detail.
An educated Saatva Vs. Casper mattress comparison should indicate which is right for you. There are many significant differences between the two, more than enough to enable you to decide which you would prefer.
When comparing the Casper Vs. Saatva mattress we shall discuss how each is made, the benefits and disadvantages of each and who would prefer one mattress rather than other. So let’s go: let the Saatva Vs. Casper mattress battle commence. We shall begin with a chart indicating the properties of each layer of the individual makes, after which we will expand on the benefits of each. We are using the Queen size as our example for comparison.
Saatva Vs. Casper Mattress Table of Contents
Saatva Vs. Casper Mattress Comparison
Shipping and Delivery
Saatva Mattress: The Saatva mattress comes with free shipping and white glove delivery. The mattress is ready for use, and your old mattress it taken away. Off-gassing is minimal; in fact, Saatva says that there is no off-gassing in their manufacturing facility.
Casper Mattress: The Casper mattress comes with free shipping and is compressed in a box. It should be taken out of the box, unwrapped and left to expand to its correct size. Off-gassing should disperse while this is happening.
Saatva Mattress: We shall begin our discussion with the construction of the Saatva Mattress. This is fundamentally an innerspring mattress with foam layers to improve comfort. There are two layers of springs: a 4-inch layer of individually foam-encased steel coils and then a 7-inch layer of traditional hourglass shaped steel springs. The lower layer provides excellent core support for this mattress, while the top layer provides good motion separation between partners.
Casper Mattress: The Casper mattress is constructed with a mix of latex, memory and polyurethane foams (commonly known as poly foams). The Casper mattress is fundamentally a Latex – Memory foam – poly foam construction. No springs for core support, although the base poly foam layer provides excellent support for all sleepers.
Saatva Mattress: The Saatva cover is made using 100% organic cotton. This cotton is breathable and helps keep you cool at night. The pillow top provides a high level of comfort to the mattress, and it aligns perfectly to the edge of the mattress. The quilting of the pillow top is focused on the middle of the mattress, offering maximum support to the middle, where most of your body weight will lie. This helps you to sleep with a more natural shape to your spine. This is a Euro-style pillow top that keeps its structure while you sleep and also adds to the life of the mattress.
Casper Mattress: The Casper cover is 100% polyester. This is a fairly porous, open weave polyester providing a soft top. The weave makes it easy for heat to escape and help the mattress cool down.
Saatva Mattress: Saatva is an innerspring mattress with a pillow top, and as such is firmer than the Casper. It is springy and bouncy, and would likely be preferred by younger couples for that reason. If you like good support and a degree of bounce for adult night-time activities, then this would be preferred to the Casper mattress
The Saatva mattress comes in three comfort levels:
- Plush Soft has a firmness of 3.5 on a scale of 1 to 10.
- Luxury Firm is 6.0.
- Firm is 8.0
Casper Mattress: Because it is 100% foam, the Casper mattress is softer, so you tend to sink into it more than with the Saatva. If you want a comfortable mattress with not too much springiness, then you would prefer the Casper mattress. Its firmness is 6-7 on a scale of 1 to 10.
The warranty is important. If your mattress is defective in any way, you need to know that your complaint will be adequately managed and quickly expedited. Here are details of the Saatva and Casper warranties:
Saatva Warranty: Nominally 15 years. If your mattress is found to be defective within the first two years after purchase, it will be replaced with a new mattress free of charge. Between 3 and 15 years, it will be repaired and recovered, but you pay $99 transportation cost for collection and re-delivery. The warranty covers body impressions more than 1.5 inches deep. It is invalid if your foundation is not a platform or box spring, or is not a metal bed frame with 5 or 6 legs.
Trial Period: 120 days. You may return the mattress within 120 days for a 100% refund if you don’t like it.
Casper Warranty: Nominally ten years. Casper will replace or repair your mattress if the workmanship is found to be defective. This includes visible indentations of more than one inch. The replacement or repair will be free of charge, although the customer will be liable for transport costs. The warranty is valid only if the mattress lies on a foundation suitable for the weight of the mattress and the user(s).
Trial Period: You can return the Casper mattress within 100 days if you don’t like for a 100% refund.
Who Would Prefer a Saatva Mattress?
You would likely prefer a Saatva mattress if:
- You like a bouncy mattress with a choice of hardness levels
- You dislike sleeping hot
- You prefer an innerspring mattress
- You don’t like feeling ‘enclosed’ in your mattress.
- You prefer to lie on top of your mattress rather than ‘in’ it.
- You don’t like off-gassing with a chemical smell.
Who Would Prefer a Casper Mattress?
You would likely prefer a Casper mattress if:
- You prefer to sleep cool but don’t like springs. The upper layer of foam in the Casper mattress is able to breathe and dissipate heat.
- You prefer a memory foam mattress to an innerspring option.
- You like the memory foam feel of sinking into your mattress slightly, but don’t like being ‘enclosed’ by it.
The Casper mattress is unlike other memory foam mattresses because it has a latex foam top. This modifies the feel of the memory foam beneath it. However, you still get that ‘sinking’ feeling when you lie on it. Some people like this while others do not. Nevertheless, this mattress feels different from regular memory foam mattresses because of that latex top.
Saatva Vs. Casper Mattress Review: Conclusion
The Saatva mattress can definitely be identified as an innerspring mattress. Both mattresses give the impression of sleeping on the mattress rather than sinking into it. Much depends on what you are used to. If you have been used sleeping on innerspring mattresses, then you will find the Saatva mattress more to your liking. Otherwise, the Casper mattress will probably attract you more.
Both have their benefits, and when viewed dispassionately, you would probably choose the Saatva mattress if you like innerspring and a slight bounce to your mattress. You would likely go for the Casper if you prefer memory foam, even though the top sleeping surface is 100% Dunlop type latex. Both are cool to sleep in and their sleep trial and warranty periods are satisfactory.